Those pictures of ultra-orthodox Jews with big beards, peyos (side curls), and black hats waving signs like “Real Torah Jews Against Israel” and “Real Jews Stand with Palestine”? The ones who are all over the news lately?
I am begging you to stop posting pictures of these people and tokenizing them into “good Jews” just because they’re more visibly Jewish than the rest of us. Stop giving this group attention.
Let’s get into the nitty gritty, shall we?
Neturei Karta (henceforth NK because I don’t feel like typing it out every time) does not believe in the current state of Israel. That’s fine. They believe Israel is an aberration because Israel can only be reformed by the Messiah. Without the Messiah, it’s a false state. They want it dissolved. Okay, fine. No problems so far. Lots of ultra-Orthodox people believe that, like the Satmars.
But let’s discuss their beliefs on the Messianic age. Most Jews believe the Messiah will bring peace on Earth and harmony. NK believes the Messiah will make Jews kings and everyone else into slaves. Yes, including Palestinians. Black and Brown people are considered subhuman, even though they’ve met with famous antisemite Louis Farrakhan.
You may be surprised by this last tidbit, but NK has no problem meeting with antisemites as long as they also oppose Israel. This includes former president of Iran, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, former Palestinian president Yasser Arafat, and leaders of Hamas and Hezbollah. Hamas, whose charter contains a line about killing all Jews.
Neturei Karta are, like their compatriots, Holocaust deniers. Yes, that sounds weird coming from Jews, but here we are. They believe that G_d would not allow such a horrible thing to happen to Jews, so it didn’t happen. Occasionally, you’ll get one to admit that the Holocaust happened, but it’s always met with the caveat of “those weren’t real Jews. Real Jews wouldn’t have died. Real Jews would have been rescued by G_d,” or, even worse, “Jews deserved the Holocaust because they were trying to assimilate. If they hadn’t been sinful, it wouldn’t have happened. The Holocaust is G_d’s punishment for Jews.” I shouldn’t need to explain why that’s offensive.
That’s why they carry signs about being “real Jews.” They believe they really are the only Jews and everyone else is an imposter. Anyone who is not one of them is not considered Jewish. They actually chanted this at Netanyahu. That’s funny because Netanyahu is an evil dictator, but (as much as I loathe to admit it) he’s still Jewish.
You’ll notice that you never see women with them, ever. Why? Because they genuinely believe women should stay in the house cooking and cleaning and having children instead of learning or interacting with the outside world. They do not teach their daughters to read, because why would you need it if you’re only going to be a wife? It also makes escaping that much harder, which is the goal. They insist that all women be “modest”, which includes demanding that women wear long skirts and hair coverings. They rip off advertisements with women on it, occasionally going after moving buses. Just recently, on Rosh Hashanah, they put up signs insisting that men walk on the curb and women walk in the street. You can’t even hold hands with your wife while you go to shul. (You’ll notice that Hamas and Hezbollah have the same opinions on women and “modesty.”) Feel free to try to talk to them if you’re a woman. Chances are they’ll pretend to only speak Yiddish or Hebrew, which has been my experience.
Of course, since NK follow the Torah exactly (which isn’t possible but don’t tell them that), they don’t believe in gay marriage. They protested Israel acknowledging gay marriages that occurred in other countries and have declared all queer people abominations.
Will you see any of that on their English website? No. They do a very good job of creating a nice facade for non-Israelis to get them on board. I’m told you can find these beliefs on their Yiddish website, but I don’t speak it so I cannot verify that.
Neturei Karta is considered a terrorist group and has met with terrorists. They’re on the watchlist for Israel and the US, which doesn’t say much, but should give you an idea that this isn’t just protesting. They’re encouraging acts of terrorism by funding the Islamic Jihad and fueling radicals to hurt Israelis.
Let’s review:
Neturei Karta is a terrorist cult that hates women, gay people, and people of color. They hate other Jews and pretend that they’re the only Jews. They believe the Holocaust is the fault of Jews not being religious enough. They tokenize Palestinians and their struggle in an attempt to get rid of Israel but don’t actually see them as people.
These are not good people. These are very bad people who appear to be doing the right thing. They look like people trying to liberate Palestine, but they don’t care what happens to them. They believe all Muslims will be slaves in the next age, but for now, they’re useful for their goals. Honestly, this is what is so offensive to me. They are using a marginalized, at risk group for their own ends while still considering them subhuman. Frankly, it’s no different than Evangelical Christians funding Israel because they believe that if all Jews go to Israel, it will trigger the End Times, even though people who deny Jesus will go to hell.
Please stop posting pictures of these people. Stop furthering their message. Stop giving attention to people who do not care if you live or die. There are plenty of good Jewish organizations to support. There’s If Not Now, Jewish Voice for Peace, and Jews for Racial and Economic Justice. Your local reform or reconstructionist synagogue will probably have more information. My congregation protested the sale of arms to Israel on Monday, and will return to protest today (October 18) at the Capitol. There are plenty of other ways to help Palestinians without tokenizing them.